Reviews for this were quite positive, so I was expecting a lot from it, but this is just no a good waterproof mascara. It doesn't just fail at holding the lashes curled, the lashes just drop down when you start applying this, despite investing several minutes in curling the lashes beforehand. It's also the only waterproof mascara I've tried that smudges and as soon as I wipe off the black line that smudges on my upper eyelid, it just reappears the next time I open my eyes. I have never encountered that even at regular mascaras. It adds a lot of volume because it's a type of formula that deposits a heavy coat on the lashes quickly, but it's poor at separation despite the silicone brush with a good length and position of bristles and you quickly get a spidery lash effect. Taking pictures of this mascara for a review was a nightmare.

I left it in the drawer for months and it's still bad. It behaves as a regular smudgy mascara with no hold, but it's equally hard to remove as waterproof mascaras. Just awful.

Just like the mascara, this didn't impress me. While it’s not quite as disappointing, the watery, partly sheer black formula and a hard, short, non-flexible applicator just don't deliver the results I'm used to from for example Catrice's eyeliners. It's hard to create a thin, precise line with this - actually impossible for my level of skill and the formula stays sheer in places even if I got over it again. I haven't tested how long it lasts, but it's not waterproof and the swatch on my hand was quite quickly removed with regular hand washing.