Mattes outnumber shimmers 5 to 4 and they also outperform them, as they are all nicely pigmented and smooth. At first they didn't blend well, but they've since become really good. There's a good selection of tones and depths, so I use this palette often for my crease, either for a natural, defined look or in combination with a shimmery shade on the eyelids. Shimmers are a mixed bag, with Constrictor in the bottom row being the best performing and most pigmented shade, while the three in the middle row are so-so. Slanted and Cold Blooded, the two side shades, are weak, not well pigmented and especially Slanted looks only like a shimmery wash on the eyelids. They aren't useless, they just don't give you the effect you expect based on the pans. The central Snake Eyes is better, but not as good as Constructor. This palette comes in cardboard packaging with no mirror, but costs the same as Coconuts, which is better packed (though less environment-friendly). 

Going Coconuts older than That's Taupe and it's the first Colourpop palette I deemed good enough to purchase, though now that I have both, I'd be a bit disappointed if I only had this one because it's warmer than I expected. It's again a combination of mattes and shimmers. 

Here mattes are again nice and all shimmers apart from Coco Crush are well performers, but even Coco Crush isn't as bad as Slanted in Taupe. Palm Reader, the shimmery white, could be smoother, but the only similar shade I have in Revolution Pro palette is the same, so maybe it's a common trait. I wish Shredded weren't so yellow because it's not the best base for my skin tone, but considering they have to cater many skin tones, I get why they didn't include something paler. Like I said above, this palette is overall warmer than Taupe, mostly on account of Shell Yeah which is leaning to orange-brown on me. This one comes in a plastic case with a mirror. Each palette costs 14$, which is reasonable.